One of the most important things to consider about spilled liquids is how fast, safe and thorough they can be removed. But other factors, such as the cost of cleaning up, also play a major role.
Companies often choose to use mineral granules for absorbing liquids, but are DENSORB mats an alternative choice? We wanted to know so we put both products to the test in a tough performance comparison.
The criteria: absorption capacity, application, cost, time and storage.
When dealing with a leak, the fewer absorbent materials used, the better. Which product has the highest absorption capacity?
|Mineral Gruanules||DENSORB Oil mats|
|Absorption Capacity||Approximately same as own weight||Up to 16 times own weight|
The excellent capillary action of the DENSORB absorbent mats ensures a uniform distribution of the absorbed liquid and therefore ensures ideal use of the absorption capacity. DENSORB absorbent mats can absorb up to 16 times more liquid than mineral granules.
More is more – the points go to DENSORB mats.
The area of application is the most important issue for an absorbent material when cleaning up leaks and spills. We have put both products to the test.
Indoors, DENSORB absorbents impress with their flexibility. In contrast to granules, they are not only suitable for cleaning up leaks, but also for many other purposes: for example as a underlay for repair, cleaning and maintenance work or for wiping down dirty surfaces and parts. They can also be used long term - for example on machinery where drips often need to be contained. DENSORB is also a real alternative to dusty granules in areas where cleanliness is required.
Mineral granules have an advantage here only in rare applications: For example, when extremely hot liquids are to be absorbed. The melting point of the DENSORB binding fleece is 160 ° C. At higher temperatures granules are the more suitable agent.
Granules are often used in outdoor areas or on roads. There is a reason for this: Granules also penetrate into small depressions, therefore enabling better fluid absorption on rough and cracked surfaces. As a result, they also ensure maximum slip resistance.
DENSORB mats have an advantage in one special application: on water. Oil absorbents in granular form have a significant disadvantage here in terms of environmental damage. A good alternative here is the use of floating DENSORB oil mats and oil barriers.
A draw! While DENSORB mats impress with their flexible application possibilities indoors and on water, granules are more appropriate for rough surfaces outdoors and for special cases such as the absorption of extremely hot liquids. Both products win a point here.
Lets be honest - cost is always going to play an important role for companies, so we've done the calculations. How much does it cost to absorb 10 litres of oil using absorbent mats compared to mineral granules?
DENSORB absorbents mats absorb oil up to 16 times their own weight. Thanks to their higher absorption capacity, less material is needed so less waste is produced. If the purchase and disposal costs are combined, this results in a total saving of 60% compared to conventional granules!
An additional benefit: when using granules you often spread more than is actually needed. DENSORB mats make it much easier to use just the right amount.
|Mineral Granules||DENSORB Oil Absorbents|
|Quantity needed||12.5 kg||
3.28 m x 0.76 m
|Disposal quantity||21.5 kg||9.95 kg|
|Disposal costs (e.g. £0.65 /kg)||£12.29||£5.69|
The point for lower costs clearly goes to DENSORB mats.
Time is money, they say. But when you're faced with a leak, losing time cleaning it up also poses an additional risk. We recorded the time our testers needed to use both products.
DENSORB absorbent mats absorbed the leaked liquid faster than the granules. DENSORB also has advantages after the cleaning up has been done - while the granules have to be swept up and scooped together, absorbent mats can be quickly collected and disposed of. Granules can also stick to shoes and spread further meaning even more work.
|Granulat aus Moleerde||DENSORB Bindevliese Öl|
|Time needed||20 minutes||3-5 minutes|
DENSORB mats win the race and pick up the point for the shortest time needed to clean up the leak.
When it comes to storage, companies want to use as little space as possible. Which product will take up the least storage space? For our test we compared the amount of absorbent materials needed to absorb 10 litres of oil.
|Mineral Granules||DENSORB Oil Absorbents|
Storage volume and quantity
|25 Litres (12.5 kg)||5 Litres (0.95 kg)|
The low weight and volume of DENSORB absorbent mats is clear - for the same absorption capacity, much less storage space is required.
Space saved – another point for DENSORB mats.
DENSORB absorbent mats are a reliable and flexible aid in many application situations, saving you time and money.
The technical information on this page has been prepared carefully and to the best of our knowledge and belief. Nevertheless, DENIOS can not assume any warranty or liability whatsoever, be it contractually, tortiously or in any other way, for timeliness, completeness and correctness neither towards the recipient of this magazine nor to third parties. The use of information and content for your own or other purposes is at your own risk. In any case, observe the local and current legislation.
|Need more information or advice? Call 01952 700 567 to speak to a DENIOS expert.|